Boston Marathon Bombing 2 Perspectives Enemy Combatant or Murderous Criminal

By Melanie Nathan, April 20, 2013.

Screen Shot 2013-04-20 at 11.08.59 AMAfter a 102 hour manhunt ending in the backyard of a Watertown residence, the capture of the Boston Marathon Bomber, yields many questions yet to be answered and  charged still to be filed.  Here are 2 of many Statements circulating in social media today commenting on the judicial process that ought to be applied:

U.S. Senator Lindsey Graham

Just put out this statement with John McCain about the suspect captured in Boston and whether they should be held as an enemy combatant.

“We truly appreciate the hard work and dedication of our law enforcement and intelligence communities.

“It is clear the events we have seen over the past few days in Boston were an attempt to kill American citizens and terrorize a major American city. The accused perpetrators of these acts were not common criminals attempting to profit from a criminal enterprise, but terrorist trying to injure, maim, and kill innocent Americans.

“Now that the suspect is in custody, the last thing we should want is for him to remain silent. It is absolutely vital the suspect be questioned for intelligence gathering purposes. We need to know about any possible future attacks which could take additional American lives. The least of our worries is a criminal trial which will likely be held years from now.

“Under the Law of War we can hold this suspect as a potential enemy combatant not entitled to Miranda warnings or the appointment of counsel. Our goal at this critical juncture should be to gather intelligence and protect our nation from further attacks.

“We remain under threat from radical Islam and we hope the Obama Administration will seriously consider the enemy combatant option.

“We will stand behind the Administration if they decide to hold this suspect as an enemy combatant.”

Center for Constitutional Rights

Our thoughts go out to the friends and families of victims of the horrific bombings in Boston. While it is difficult to turn to points of law in times of tragedy, those are, in fact, the times we most need to cling to the values, laws and rights that make us who we are as a nation.

The government has decided not to read the suspect in the Boston Marathon bombings his Miranda rights before interrogating him for what is now the longest exception to date.

The Miranda warnings were put in place because police officers were beating and torturing “confessions” out of people who hadn’t even been formally accused of a crime. We cannot afford to repeat our mistakes. If officials require suspects to incriminate themselves, they are making fair trials and due process merely option and not a requirement. To venture down that road again will make law enforcement accountable to no one.

Like Obama’s expanded killing program and his perpetuation of indefinite detention without trial at Guantanamo, this is yet another erosion of the Constitution to lay directly at the President’s feet. Obama’s Justice Department unilaterally expanded the “public safety exception” to Miranda in 2010 beyond anything the Supreme Court ever authorized. Each time the administration use this exception, it stretches wider and longer. However horrific the crime, continuing to erode constitutional rights invites continued abuse by law enforcement, and walks us down a dangerous path that becomes nearly impossible to reverse.

What do you think?

My Opinion:

To call this suspected murderer an enemy combatant is to validate his quest – for consideration that his ideological motive distinguished him in a way that he considers positive! I think calling him such is falling into the hands of other future “home-growns” so called “terrorists.”  Personally I would rather call them “mass murderers” – criminals – and give them less cause to receive help from ACLU and Civil Liberties Union – all of whom will rush to the rescue if we dare call them ‘enemy combatants,’ which will only serve to give their warped ideology publicity.   I think if we buy into the stupidity (politicizing) of the Republicans calling for such, we will be feeding the motivation for more “home growns.”   Damn some of those Senators are idiots!

UPDATE 4/22/2013.

The White House said Monday that despite the demands of some congressional Republicans, the lone surviving suspect in the Boston Marathon bombings will not be tried as an “enemy combatant” but will face trial in U.S. federal court. White House spokesman Jay Carney added that under U.S. law, American citizens such as Dzhokhar Tsarnaev cannot be tried by military commissions.

Boston bombing suspect charged with using weapon of mass destruction

Boston Marathon bombing suspect Dzhokhar Tsarnaev was charged Monday with one count of using a weapon of mass destruction against persons and property and one count of malicious destruction of property by means of an explosive device resulting in death, the Justice Department announced Monday.  Read more at:

  • US Attorney in Aaron Swartz – No miranda rights to Boston Marathon Suspect (
  • What rights should Dzhokhar Tsarnaev get and why does it matter? | Glenn Greenwald (

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

3 Comments on “Boston Marathon Bombing 2 Perspectives Enemy Combatant or Murderous Criminal”

  1. Cathy Kristofferson April 20, 2013 at 11:33 AM #

    I believe he should be read his Miranda rights. He is a U.S. citizen after all. I am happy to ignore Lindsey Graham and anything emanating from that wing of the political sphere. I understand the concept of ‘public safety exception’ and can see how it could apply in this case since multiple additional bombs – of both the pressure cooker and pipe varieties – have not only been thrown about the streets of greater Boston but have been found in the suspects’ apartment following the initial bombing. It also seems plausible that determining from the remainder of the two suspects whether they worked alone or in concert with others now planning more attacks as something in the public safety category. However, I have been constantly disappointed in the trampling of civil rights perpetrated by the Obama administration. There is no way to know if the length of time that has past is due to his physical condition and perhaps inability to participate in questioning of the public safety issues, or if simply further overreach of the federal government. And for me here in MA, ‘federal government’ is important for folks to remember. ‘We’, the lefty liberals, are not in control here. The DOJ is.

    • Melanie Nathan April 20, 2013 at 12:49 PM #

      I see no reason to follow Lindsay Graham’s plan. I also think the ideology of the enemy would want the martyrdom of enemy combatant – its handing their terror to them on plate as if to say they won a valid status. I think its counters their ideological quest if we treat them like common criminals.

  2. Cheyenne&Mari April 22, 2013 at 12:16 PM #

    Hey Guys ssfbc, but it is really important and if you can please pass it along to friends and family…

    As you all may have heard, there is a serial killer on the loose targeting Gay people.This is a serious matter and police aren’t taking it seriously. New information is that members of the police are involved and that it may even be a group. Source has let out that these “people” are now hitting the web media and luring gay people out via Facebook,mxit,twitter and all forms of web chat rooms

    I care enough to warn all my fellow gay friends and family to please be careful, these men are inhumane and will not stop unless we are able to stop it ourselves!!!!

    Take extra caution when meeting an internet encounter or even, when applying for jobs and make sure it’s in a public place… Also let people know of your wearabouts at all times!!!
    BE GAY
    BE CAREFUL!!!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 441 other followers

Build a website with
%d bloggers like this: