HRC Calls in San Francisco Police for LGBT Castro Protest

Peaceful Protest attracts curious tourists, reporters and Castro community

By Melanie Nathan, January 31, 2015.

Screen Shot 2015-01-31 at 2.55.55 PM
Melanie Nathan protests outside HRC store in the Castro

About 2 dozen LGBT activists from San Francisco and community members held a vigil outside the San Francisco Human Rights Campaign (HRC) souvenir store in the Castro today. The gathering, which took the form of a sidewalk noon brunch, outside the old Harvey Milk Camera store, was organized in solidarity with the ACT UP New York demonstration taking place this evening at the HRC Gala being held at the Waldorf Astoria. Another solidarity demonstration is expected in Washington D.C. today, at the HRC building.

Picture: Bill Wilson

Though billed publicly as a peaceful protest, HRC had called for a police presence in advance of the protest. When activists arrived, there were already 4 SFPD officers standing  on the street.  Activists unfurled a gigantic rainbow flag and waved signs outside the store,  chanting “BAD BAD HRC,” while curious tourists and community members were offered snacks and an explanation as to why we were there.

The peaceful demonstration continued for an hour. After the demonstrators left a police officer was photographed entering the HRC Store.

“It is our hope that HRC will take note of the myriad of issues and grievances and talk to activists from outside their organization in collaboration on these issues impacting our local and global communities.” (Melanie Nathan to KPFA Radio.)

SFPD | Pic: Bill Wilson
SFPD | Pic: Bill Wilson

Several members of the press showed up, including international journalists and TV. We were also interviewed by KPFA radio. We hope that HRC will start to embrace the grass roots by talking to us about the issues that impact us as a community rather than continue to distance itself, in what seems to be a despotic type leadership role. We also hope that HRC will look at how it spends its money and consider how it can impact direct services for LGBT members of our communities.

Pic: Bill Wilson.
Pic: Bill Wilson.

Activists provided the following reasons for their protest: 

HRC touts itself as the preeminent organization in leadership on LGBT issues in the USA and is now also treading into global waters. It should lead authentically, holistically and effectively, as it once did, but that is no longer the case. Instead it is an autocratic organization, which assumes an exclusionary and elitist leadership role. It tricks members of Congress and community into thinking that it represents all our voices, but it does not.

Today we protested in solidarity to support ACT UP NEW YORK, which is protesting at the HRC Gala at the Waldorf Astoria tonight. ACT UP is protesting HRC who they deem soft on HIV/AIDS and the critical issue of Homeless Queer Youth.

They are protesting the fund raising gala that excludes the majority of HRC members who cannot afford to be there because of the high priced tickets, showing an elite bias. While HRC takes most of its money from the 99% through huge national and global membership, it applauds and congratulates only the 1%,  while further ignoring many of the needs of the 99%.

Melnaie and chinese media

Screen Shot 2015-01-31 at 2.56.56 PM
Activists included a homeless transgender person as well as a diverse group of community members.

Here is a list of grievances:

  • No concern for needs of poor and low income LGBTI people;
  • No agenda promoting affordable housing, a living wage and access to higher education;
  • No action response to the national outcry against police killing Black, Brown & Transgender people;
  • No global plan that respects the work of local LGBTI folks and group’s working on international issues;
  • No incorporation of progressive and economic justice concerns in HRC’s Corporate Equality Index – PINKWASHING certain corporations;
  • HRC MUST STOP supporting The Employment Non Discrimination Act (ENDA) and RELIGIOUS BIGOTRY;
  • HRC is soft on HIV /AIDS;
  • HRC sucks LGBT donor dollars without putting anything back into direct services such as Homeless Queer Youth, Asylum seekers and refugees; and
  • Fund raise by claiming victories to the exclusion of other LGBT organizations and grass root community and activists who played major roles in such victories.

BAD BAD HRCHRC PINKWASHING:  HRC runs a Corporate Equality Index, rating US workplaces based on equality hiring. This serves only to PINKWASH the grievances we have with some of the corporations pertaining to social and environmental issues.

HRC notes the importance of businesses understanding and honoring the issues important to LGBTI people. They provide an Equality Score Index , which LGBT people can look at to see who we should support with our buying power. They say on their website “these issues range from LGBT inclusiveness to environmental protection.

Pic: Bill Wilson
Pic: Bill Wilson

Corporate social responsibility has become an imperative for a successful business.” Yet they give high scores to certain corporations which have terrible environmental records and who are not praiseworthy because of other issues. This means HRC is using the LGBT positive aspects to ‘Pinkwash’ the company. To provide a high score to a corporation that is bad on the environment, compromises who we are as an equality and human rights conscious community. Just because they have a fair diversity hiring policy, does not mean we should elevate a company that is bad on other issues.

Screen Shot 2015-01-31 at 4.02.52 PMHRC notes: “In the 2015 CEI report, 366 major businesses — spanning nearly every industry and geography — earned a top score of 100 percent and the distinction of “Best Places to Work for LGBT Equality.” The Report is merely a survey to employers – and is based on Employers self ratings. Its results serve to elevate businesses which may not deserve such praise on many issues that concern us, not only as a LGBT community, but also as a community concerned with the well being of all Americans and the world at large.

Case in point General Electric gets a 100% score. GE has recently been sued and either guilty or settled for age, race and sex discrimination.

ENDA: and religious Bigotry: HRC claims the 2013 Senate passage of ENDA is a victory. It is not. Accepting and praising religious bigotry is never a victory. This has misled the US LGBT community for 2 years now. HRC was last at the table to reconsider ditching its support for an ENDA that is fraught with religious exemptions that are prejudicial to the LGBT community.


[email protected]



Updated: 3 Cities many complaints – HRC targeted today by activists in NY, D.C. and SF!!

HRC protests Act Up and Dc


HERE IS THE D.C. ACTION in a trilogy of protests against HRC



Screen Shot 2015-02-02 at 7.41.17 AM

Screen Shot 2015-02-02 at 7.36.15 AM

On Santa’s Naughty List HRC Gets Coal Delivery

…and the letter from Santa tells Chad why! Santa Claus asked the members of (1AOL) if they wouldn’t mind delivering a letter to the Human Rights Campaign (HRC), and they merrily agreed. Though the weather outside was frightful, their spirits were high as they donned their rainbow Santa hats while listening to the mood setting Perry Como’s “Santa […]

HRC Now Accepts Religious Liberty Bigotry

by Cathy Kristofferson, January 11, 2015 Today, the Human Rights Campaign (HRC) received their first lump of coal from Santa for 2015. Deliverers of Santa’s naughty list and coal at Christmastime,, returned barely two weeks into the new year following Thursday’s Washington Post article in which HRC’s vice president Fred Sainz gushed over presidential hopeful Jeb Bush’s new […]

Activists at DC Pride attack HRC’s Bad ENDA

While asking the community to demand no less than full federal equality… By Cathy Kristofferson, June 8, 2014 This week saw the first national organization come out strongly against the flawed Employment Non-Discrimination Act of 2013 (ENDA) when the National Center for Lesbian Rights (NCLR) Thursday announced it “We strongly oppose any religious exemption in ENDA… we will […]

5 Comments Continue Reading →

NCLR Takes A stand Against Onerous ENDA While HRC Fights for It

#ENDAIsNOTequal #DeadENDA #ENDENDA #WTFHRC By Melanie Nathan, June 05, 2014. Washington Blade is reporting that The National Center for Lesbian Rights (NCLR)  announced today that it does not support the current version of the Employment Non-Discrimination Act pending before Congress because of the bill’s religious exemption. A schism has developed amongst activists with grassroots pitted […]

2 Comments Continue Reading →

HRC Boots Activist Protesting ENDA’s Broad Religious Exemptions

7 thoughts on “HRC Calls in San Francisco Police for LGBT Castro Protest

  1. Pingback: HRC Calls in San Francisco Police for LGBT Castro Protest | Daily Queer News
  2. Reblogged this on It Is What It Is and commented:
    I used to be an HRC member … not anymore since my eyes were opened!

  3. Pingback: Marriage Equality Round-Up - February 1st
  4. Pingback: DC joins NY and SF protesting HRC pinkwashing | 1 Angry Old Lesbian
  5. I don’t like it that they take money from corporations like Chevron that dumped millions of gallons of oil in the Ecuadorian rain forest and refused to clean it up and also the Richmond fire in the bay area which has bad effects on children’s lungs and people of color.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s