LGBT Leaders Call on Task Force for Independent Review of Creating Change Debacle

By Melanie Nathan January 28, 2016.

Screen Shot 2016-01-23 at 1.22.51 PMI am proud to be a signatory to this letter addressed to the LGBTQ Task Force. I am also proud to stand with noted and admired leaders in our community.  The letter speaks for itself.  Thank you to Roberta Kaplan and Rabbi Sharon Kleinbaum for leading the effort on this powerful message:

Some background appears article by Jonathan Capehart of The Washington Post, where our letter is referenced:

“The annual Creating Change conference convened by the National LGBTQ Task Force is a premier gathering of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and questioning (LGBTQ) activists and leaders from around the country and the world. As Mark Joseph Stern of Slate notes, it “brings together dozens of LGBTQ groups, from fringe to mainstream, at one bustling summit to compare notes and debate strategy.”

But this year’s bustling summit blew up when some 200 protesters rallied against a San Francisco-based Jewish group holding a reception during the conference. The demonstrators accused A Wider Bridge, which seeks to foster ties between Israel and LGBT communities in North America, of engaging in “pinkwashing.” That is, portraying a positive view of Israel while distracting from that nation’s treatment of Palestinians.”

Reporting on the demonstrations paints a chaotic scene of provocation, invective and reaction, as do the videos. One video in particular was especially disturbing because of what was being chanted…..  “

I wrote about the protests and in no uncertain  terms referred to the flagrant anti-Semitism that emanated from reports and videos:  “LGBT Protesters at Creating Change Call for the Destruction of Israel,” SEE MY ARTICLE – describing events

Here is the Letter from noted LGBT leaders in the U.S.A.:

Letter to the LGBTQ Task Force

January 27, 2016

TO: Rea Carey, Executive Director, National LGBTQ Task Force

We send this letter as members and leaders of the LGBTQ community. Some of us are Jewish; some of us are not. Some of us have spent time visiting or living in the State of Israel; some have not. Indeed, like the population of Israel itself, we have diverse, and often sharply conflicting, views about the difficult issues raised by the Palestinian-Israeli conflict and the best way to resolve them.

What we all do share is our history and experience in connection with the struggle for LGBTQ equality in the United States and elsewhere. Many of us have not only contributed significantly to the enormous strides that have been made towards LGBTQ equality in recent years, but have devoted our lives and careers to that cause. The purpose of this letter is to unequivocally express our collective and deep concern about what transpired at the Task Force’s 2016 Creating Change Conference in Chicago, Illinois (CC16) on Friday, January 22, 2016 with respect to A Wider Bridge, an organization that fosters relationships between Israel and the LGBT community (AWB), and the Jerusalem Open House of Pride and Tolerance (JOH).

While some of us were at the conference to witness the events of January 22, there were also a number of published reports. More than one hundred protesters succeeded in physically intimidating and ultimately shutting down a reception organized by AWB featuring Israeli speakers from JOH. It has been reported — and videos taken contemporaneously confirm — that the protesters chanted slogans like “Palestine will be free from the river to the sea,” which necessarily suggests that the State of Israel should no longer exist. Another protester shouted, “We are going to challenge these Zionist racist motherfuckers.” There were also reports of altercations between the protesters and the reception guests. Witnesses saw a man get into a scuffle with the protesters and have his yarmulke knocked off his head. In a separate incident, there is a report of an individual who was called “kike.”

We applaud the fact that the initial decision by Task Force staff to stop AWB and JOH from hosting a reception in the CC16 was reversed by the Task Force. We are aware that the 100–200 protesters were among a conference of 4,000 participants and have no reason to believe that what transpired outside the reception on January 22 reflects the views or experiences of the majority of the 4000 conference goers. We also know that there is a Jewish Movement Building Working Group as part of the Task Force’s Creating Change conference, which has, for many years, done important work ensuring Jewish voices are an integral part of the conference and conversation.

Nevertheless, the events of January 22 in Chicago were unacceptable and not in accord with the Task Force’s values of pluralism, inclusivity and thoughtful debate. The targeted organizations’ reception was disrupted and shut down by protesters (including people not attending the conference) with such hostility and aggression that speakers and attendees at the event were justifiably terrified and felt physically threatened. We are united in our belief that what transpired at CC16 was dangerous, deeply disturbing, and given the use of epithets like “kike,” clearly anti-Semitic.

The larger question posed by all of this is where do we as a progressive social movement go from here? What is the Task Force’s responsibility in this situation? What values does the Task Force wish to embody? We understand that the Task Force has undertaken to conduct a review of its policies in this regard and we congratulate that decision. We believe that the review should be conducted by an outside, independent party charged with determining what happened, how it happened, and what will be done to ensure that it will not happen again.

We also believe that the Task Force as well as all other LGBTQ organizations need to consider and adopt some form of an “active pluralism” policy with respect to these issues. Such a policy, while respecting the free speech rights of individuals and groups, would not allow protesters to effectively censor the speech of other groups, much less threaten the physical well-being and safety of those with whom they do not agree, including Jewish and Israeli LGBTQ groups. Given the concentrated and organized hostility that is so often displayed against Jewish and Israeli LGBTQ groups, and the stark rise in global anti-Semitism, it is even more important that we as a community promote civil and respectful debate. It is intellectually, politically and morally dishonest to claim that in the name of freedom, liberation, or some other progressive ideal, there is a right to target and exclude Jewish/Israeli groups, to foment physical intimidation and harassment, and to encourage anti-Semitism.

There is a long and ugly history of this kind of censorship where individuals with controversial ideas and viewpoints have been silenced in the name of the “greater good.” We should know by now that such censorship results in fewer (not more) good ideas and greater (not lesser) oppression of us all. Indeed, given that we come from a movement where LGBTQ people were effectively shut out from participation in the public discourse for so many years, what happened at CC16 was extremely dangerous. If we as a movement really believe in the values we profess to hold dear, then it is time to put an end to this.


Aaron Belkin, Founding Director, Palm Center & Professor, San Francisco State University

Dana Beyer, Executive Director, Gender Rights Maryland

The Reverend Dr. Neil G. Cazares-Thomas, Senior Pastor, Cathedral of Hope

Rabbi Lisa Edwards, Ph.D., Congregation Beth Chayim Chadashim

Rabbi Denise Eger, Congregation Kol Ami & President, Central Conference of American Rabbis of the Union of Reform Judaism

Lillian Faderman, Author and Professor, California State University— Fresno

The Honorable Barney Frank, Former Member, U.S. House of Representatives

Frank Giaou, President, World Congress of GLBT Jews

The Honorable Deborah Glick, Member, New York State Assembly

Emily Hecht-McGowan, Interim Executive Director, Equality Council

The Honorable Brad Hoylman, Member, New York State Senate

The Honorable Corey Johnson, Member, New York City Council

Alex Halpern Levy, Former LGBT adviser to U.S. Senator Charles Schumer

The Reverend Susan Hrostowski, Ph.D., LMSW, Vicar, St. Elizabeth Episcopal Church & Associate Professor, and Chair, Institutional Diversity Committee, University of Southern Mississippi

Vincent Jones, LGBT Activist and Philanthropist

Miryam Kabakov, Executive Director, Eshel

Roberta A. Kaplan, Partner, Paul Weiss LLP & Lead Counsel, U.S. vs. Windsor

Idit Klein, Executive Director, Keshet

Rabbi Sharon Kleinbaum, Congregation Beit Simchat Torah

Rabbi Michael A. Latz, Congregation Shir Tikvah

Arthur Leonard, Professor, New York Law School & Editor, LGBT Law Notes

The Honorable Mark Leno, Member, California State Assembly

Rabbi Joshua Lesser, Congregation Bet Haverim

Amichai Lau-Levie, Spiritual Leader, Lab/Shul NYC

Rabbi Ellen Lippmann, Kolot Chayeinu/Voices of Our Lives: Building a Progressive Jewish Community in Brooklyn

Seth Madnick Marin, Associate Director, ADL Legal Affairs & Civil Rights Regional Counsel

Melanie Nathan, Executive Director, Africa Human Rights Coalition

Reverend Elder Troy D. Perry, Founder, Metropolitan Community Church

The Honorable Christine Quinn, Former Speaker, New York City Council & CEO, Women in Need

Nicole Murray-Ramirez, Chair/ Executive Director, International Imperial Court Council of USA, Canada and Mexico

Lee Rubin, Former Board Chair, NGLTF

Steven Rudner, Chair, Board of Directors, Equality Texas

Robert Saferstein, Founder, Eighteen:22, A Global Network for Change. The Next Chapter of LGBTQ Jewish Life

Andrea Shorter, Co-Founder, Bayard Rustin LGBTQ Coalition

Melissa Sklarz, Former Co-Chair, National Stonewall Democrats

Andrew Tobias, Treasurer, Democratic National Committee

Rabbi Rachel Timoner, Congregation Beth Elohim

Robin Tyler, Executive Director, The Equality Campaign

Alan Van Capelle, Former Executive Director, Empire State Pride Agenda

Rabbi Deborah Waxman, Ph.D, President, Reconstructionist Rabbinical College/Jewish Reconstructionist Communities

The Honorable Scott Weiner, Member, San Francisco Board of Supervisors

Edie Windsor, Plaintiff, United States v. Windsor

Evan Wolfson, Former Executive Director, Freedom to Marry

Organizational Affiliations Listed for Identification Purposes Only
List in Formation


UPDATED: January 30, 2016:

Thanks You from A Wider bridge


3 thoughts on “LGBT Leaders Call on Task Force for Independent Review of Creating Change Debacle

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s